Welcome to Good Surgeon Bad Surgeon

The right place to find the right plastic surgeon for you. You can post reviews for cosmetic plastic surgeons in Toronto and area to make choosing the right cosmetic plastic surgeon easier for you. Highly reviewed surgeons on this site include Dr. Frank Lista, Dr. Frank Carman, Dr. Sammy Slewin, Dr. Hugh McLean, and Dr. Jerome Edelstein. These are some of the best surgeons in the GTA and are committed to providing the safest and most professional cosmetic plastic surgery on the market today.

Tell us about your experience!

Were you pleased with the results or terrified to leave your house after? Did it change the way you felt about yourself? Would you recommend your surgeon to your best friend? What did you love about your surgeon and what did you hate? We want to know and GoodSurgeonBadSurgeon.com has created a reviewing board for you to read what people really think about the work their plastic surgeon has done. Scroll through to read patient reviews and feel free to post your own. Let us know which clinic you chose and tell us all about your experience; did your surgeon have a nice personality? Did you feel comfortable during your stay at the clinic? Share this website with your friends and co-workers who are thinking about going under the knife so they know exactly what to expect and don’t have to waste time meeting with surgeons who don’t have what it is they’re looking for.

Top 4 Plastic Surgery Clinics in Canada

#1 RANKED DR. SAMMY SLIWIN

Forest Hill Institute of Aesthetic Plastic Surgery

www.sliwinplasticsurgery.com

Dr. Sliwin is a highly dedicated and attentive surgeon who consistently delivers amazing results to happy patients seeking cosmetic...
Learn More



Overall Rating. 8.63 / 10


#2 RANKED DR. HUGH McLEAN

Dr. Hugh McLean

www.mcleanclinic.com

Dr. McLean graduated from the Faculty of Medicine at the University of Toronto and has since completed specialized plastic surgery training in both Toronto and...
Learn More



Overall Rating. 7.69 / 10


#3 RANKED DR. JEROME EDELSTEIN

Dr. Jerome Edelstein

www.edelsteincosmetic.com

Dr. Edelstein has over 15 years of experience as a plastic surgeon with specialized training in cosmetic surgery and currently works at the...
Learn More



Overall Rating. 7.56 / 10


#4 RANKED DR. FRANK LISTA

Dr. Frank Lista

www.theplasticsurgeryclinic.com

Dr. Lista is on the forefront of plastic surgery in North America. He is both the founder and the director of The Plastic...
Learn More



Overall Rating. 7.28 / 10


#5 RANKED DR. WAYNE CARMAN

Dr. Wayne Carman

www.drcarmanplasticsurgery.com

A member of the Royal College of Surgeons of Canada in Plastic Surgery, Dr. Carman has practiced in private clinics for...
Learn More



Overall Rating. 7.12 / 10


#1

Ranked

Overall Rating. 8.63 / 10

DR. SAMMY SLIWIN

Feeling way more confident!!

My experience with Dr. Sammy Sliwin was amazing, and I’d recommend him to anyone! He’s such a friendly and warm doctor, and has a super helpful and caring staff! He has got to be one of the best plastic surgeons in the whole city. There are a lot of doctors in this city and I...

Read Review

A whole new me

I can’t believe how much I love the way my eyes look after getting an eyelid lift! I hadn’t really planned on plastic surgery until a friend of mine recommended Dr. Sammy Sliwin. She had her nose done by him and she looked so fantastic that I decided to book a consultation...

Read Review

View All Reviews
#2

Ranked

Overall Rating. 7.69 / 10

DR. HUGH McLEAN

Lifted Breasts and a Lifted Spirit

Wow, I can’t believe the transformation of my breasts! I’ve had 3 children and it was really important to me to nurse them for as long as I could. I’m so happy I was able to offer that care to my children, and I wouldn’t trade it for anything, but my breasts were...

Read Review

Feeling Transformed

Dr. Hugh McLean is great at what he does. I had a 3-day facelift, which was perfect for me and my lifestyle. I’m busy at work and couldn’t take off much time from work, so it was so convenient to have a speedy recovery and be able to get back to my job quickly. Not to...

Read Review

View All Reviews
#3

Ranked

Overall Rating. 7.56 / 10

DR. JEROME EDELSTEIN

My new nose is awesome

Dr. Edelstein’s a great and professional surgeon - I can’t believe how natural my new nose looks! It looks perfect with the rest of my face, and he gave me great advice about my options and really helped me through the recovery process. I feel way more confident and...

Read Review

Loving my Tummy Tuck!

Dr. Edelstein is a great surgeon. I’ve never liked my belly, and it was way worse after I had twins. My self-esteem was way down but Dr. Edelstein gave me a whole new look. My belly is way sexier and I feel so much more confident. I can wear clothes now that I never would’ve...

Read Review

View All Reviews
#4

Ranked

Overall Rating. 7.28 / 10

DR. FRANK LISTA

Breast augmentation gave me a hot new look!

Dr. Lista is beyond amazing! He’s not only super talented and professional, but he’s so warm and friendly. I felt really at ease in our appointments, and by the time I’d gotten through the consultation, I knew for sure I wanted to book a breast augmentation appointment at...

Read Review

Happy with my new nose

I went to Dr. Lista for my nose job and he did a great job. I was kind of embarrassed to book the consultation, but the truth is I was always interested in having my nose done. Dr. Lista helped me feel more comfortable about the procedure and I decided I could really trust him...

Read Review

View All Reviews
#5

Ranked

Overall Rating. 7.12 / 10

DR. WAYNE CARMAN

Way more Comfortable

Dr. Carman did my breast reduction and I feel so much healthier, happier, stronger and more attractive! My breasts had been way too big for years and it was really hard on my back, but Dr. Carman did a great job and I feel way better.

Read Review

A great surgeon for nose jobs

I’m so happy I went to Dr. Carman for my nose job. He does great work and is so professional and reliable. He gave me all the info I needed, and he gave me a fantastic new nose! I feel so confident about my new look, thanks so much Dr. Carman.

Read Review

View All Reviews
Rate this Clinic:

Note: Please only post reviews if you are a current user with this clinic or have been in the past so that this information is as accurate as possible.

Plastic Surgery Clinic Rating

#1Ranked

DR. SAMMY SLIWIN

Avg 8.63 / 10

#2Ranked

DR. HUGH McLEAN

Avg 7.69 / 10

#3Ranked

DR. JEROME EDELSTEIN

Avg 7.56 / 10

#4Ranked

DR. FRANK LISTA

Avg 7.28 / 10

#5Ranked

DR. WAYNE CARMAN

Avg 7.12 / 10